Old Time Candy Reviews
Our Customers' Reviews and Testimonials
Showing 1-100 of 9092.
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Nothing!! Love them just the way they are!! Yummy!!!Mary, Philadelphia, PA
September 18, 2025
Boyer's Mallo Cups:
Another one from my past. Tasted the same as I remember.Kenneth, Wolfe City, TX
September 18, 2025
Candy Corn:
This candy corn is by far the freshest candy corn I have EVER eaten. It tastes delicious and unfortunately is gonna be gone way too soon. I will just have to order more before the season is over. I'm not kidding! Best I've ever eaten.Cindy, Canton, MI
September 17, 2025
Smarties:
This was my "Go-To" treat for my child for years. Now I get to treat the grandkids.Mary, Holt, MI
September 17, 2025
Smarties:
One of my favorites from MANY years ago. I always used to say, after you had a Dum Dum lollipop, you HAD to eat a roll of Smarties to counteract!!!Susan, Mays Landing, NJ
September 16, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Too soft. I usually buy them from other companies, having the consistency in size and texture as regular marshmallows.Edwin, Granville, NY
September 14, 2025
Charleston Chew:
Brought back childhood memories, The chocolate and marshmallow combination can not be beat with this.Eva, Greenville, MI
September 10, 2025
Candy Necklaces (Wrapped):
This was a gift and 2 kids plus an adult loved them.Sandra, Hartford, NY
September 9, 2025
Candy Corn:
This is excellent quality candy corn. They are a little smaller than the candy corn I'm used to, but they have excellent flavor.David, Mexico, MO
September 9, 2025
Smarties:
I love the sweet and sour taste and I will definitely buy morePamela, Harrison, GA
September 6, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
This was the wrong choice on my part, where they did remind me of Grandma I put them in the wrong container and they stuck together... however I will buy more around ChristmasCarolyn, La Crosse, WI
September 4, 2025
Candy Corn:
I love candy corn and these are very fresh and taste delicious.Margaret, Brooklyn, NY
September 3, 2025
Creme Drops:
These creme drops taste just like they did years ago...they are a true treat!!Patricia, South Bend, IN
August 31, 2025
Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped):
Absolutely love these! I can nearly eat my weight in them because they're so good.Michealle, Miramar, FL
August 31, 2025
Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped):
Prefect amount of sweetness and crunch to satisfy when wanting something on the sweeter side.Bradley, Nutley, NJ
August 29, 2025
Bit-O-Honey:
These are so good you will want to eat a the whole bag!Angie, KIRKLAND, WA
August 28, 2025
Hershey's Miniatures:
My grandson loves using this Hershey's assortment of mini candy bars to make his s'mores on weekend stays when we have campfires. A great selection with some of our old favorites.SHAU, Holcombe, WI
August 27, 2025
Reese's Mini Peanut Butter Cups:
All were received in excellent quality As always the products were PERFECTCarlyn, Saint Louis, MO
August 26, 2025
Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped):
Nice flavor - enjoy the small individually wrapped snack as a quick sweet treat.Marie, Albany, NY
August 18, 2025
Good & Plenty:
So much fresher than the ones you buy in the store!Make-up, Northridge, CA
August 18, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
These little treats are complex with crunchy toasted coconut outside and the soft, sweet marshmallow inside. They were popular when I was a kid many years ago and Nuts.com has made them even better and more memorable now!Denise, Fort Pierce, FL
August 17, 2025
Caramels:
Love the caramels, they taste just like they did in the old days.Amy, Tavares, FL
August 17, 2025
Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped):
I absolutely LOVE the taste and freshness of these sesame crunch candies. DELICIOUS!!Chanique, Woodbridge, VA
August 15, 2025
Charleston Chew:
This was my second purchase of Charleston Chews. They're just like the traditional ones. Very satisfying, bite-sized little goodies. Recommended.Monica, Boulder Creek, CA
August 15, 2025
Boyer's Mallo Cups:
Yum! Bite-sized, individually packaged, made with good chocolate instead of that waxy stuff. My only concern is how messy they are; the marshmallow sticks to the paper wrappers a lot, and that's lost marshmallow goodness. Still, recommended for that old-time taste. Very fresh.Monica, Boulder Creek, CA
August 15, 2025
Bit-O-Honey:
Candy was fresh and delicious. Arrived without incident.Debra, Indianapolis, IN
August 11, 2025
Candy Corn:
One of my all-time faves! Most stores only carry these during Halloween. Thanks to Nuts.com I can enjoy them anytime now!John, Hurst, TX
August 9, 2025
Candy Corn:
Your candy corn is the best! Fresh, soft & chewy, tastes real, no artificial aftertaste...Ann, Queensbury, NY
August 9, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Omg! I have a marshmallow problem! These are insane! I’m in trouble now!Christine, Nazareth, PA
August 9, 2025
Bit-O-Honey:
My favorite! So much better than store baught. Side and chewy! So much flavor!Denise, Commerce City, CO
August 5, 2025
Bit-O-Honey:
Taste great just like I remember when I was young.Individually wrapped which is niceNancy, Charlotte, MI
August 5, 2025
Creme Drops:
When growing up as a child, Santa always brought a big bowl of these creme drops. I can't remember gifts that I got but always remember this candy. It is my comfort snack nowGinny, Columbia, MO
August 4, 2025
Peppermint Sticks:
I have ordered these before and will order again. They are of high quality and arrive intact with no broken pieces.Wendy, Winter Springs, FL
August 4, 2025
Candy Pebbles:
I love these and am so disappointed to find them sold out! love to set these out on tables when I'm entertaining--people find them amusing at first, then really love the different flavors. Sometimes I put them in small jars with a bow and give them as unique gifts. Please get these back soon!Denise, Centreville, VA
August 4, 2025
Good & Plenty:
A family favorite, and it is always fresh which is very important when eating Good and Plenty.Jacqueline, Orland Park, IL
July 29, 2025
Caramels:
Great real Caramel homemade taste. Lowered by one star because they are individually wrapped in clear plastic that is hell to remove.JP, New Port Richey, FL
July 28, 2025
Hot Tamales:
Perfect amount of spicy hot cinnamon flavor. Reminds me of childhood hot tamales that made my nose run. These are soooo good!!Rebecca, Orlando, FL
July 28, 2025
Necco Wafers:
Husband is from massachusetts, and this is his most beloved Candy.Kimberley, Port Orange, FL
July 27, 2025
Bit-O-Honey:
Love these things. Been eating them for many, many years.Robert, Milton, DE
July 24, 2025
Necco Wafers:
Big hit for candy that has been around as long as I can remember. At the get together, all ages from 3 to 89 ! Fun timeElaine, Huntington, WV
July 22, 2025
Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped):
Used to get these at a chinese restaurant in town, hadn't had them in MANY years. Then I bit my cheek eating them the other day have not tried since, that hurt REAL bad...vernon, Concord, NH
July 22, 2025
Peppermint Sticks:
I'm addicted to these. Love that the peppermint isn't too strong. Made my day when I found these here.Sharon, Jupiter, FL
July 19, 2025
Candy Necklaces (Wrapped):
Wanted these for our granddaughter- loved these as a kid!Joan, Anderson Island, WA
July 19, 2025
Good & Plenty:
When these are fresh, they are the best thing ever. I did get a couple bags that were not fresh a few years back, but this year's crop is right on the money.Cheryl, Sanford, NC
July 14, 2025
Reese's Mini Peanut Butter Cups:
Delicious...just like the bigger ones only bite size!Linda, Whitehall, PA
July 13, 2025