Old Time Candy Reviews
Our Customers' Reviews and Testimonials
Showing 1-100 of 9560.
Ribbon Candy:
Excellent candy. Reminds me of my childhood at Christmas time. Look forward for reorders.Stephen, Cibolo, TX
January 7, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Extremely tasty Christmas candy! Childhood treat. Cannot go wrong with a bag!Stephen, Cibolo, TX
January 7, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Delicious. Just like I remember from when I was a kidJean, Fishers, IN
January 6, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Everything was good like like the ribbon candy the most. Great delivery.Roxanne, Philadelphia, PA
January 5, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
My mother always had them on the holiday. They bring back memories.Marie, Upland, PA
January 5, 2026
Good & Plenty:
I love that they were a different shape. A handful is fantastic❤️Marie, Upland, PA
January 5, 2026
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Sooooo good !! Coconut nice and toasty and the marshmallow nice and soft and fresh !Ruth, Somerset, MA
January 5, 2026
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Plump and creamy. The coconut is delightful! Fast becoming a favorite!Kristy, Holland, MI
January 5, 2026
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
OMG! these are the best things I've ever snacked (inhaled) on. Will definitely order again!ANDREA, peoria, AZ
January 4, 2026
Creme Drops:
100% reminds me of Christmas at my grandparent's house. Every year they always had these around Christmas time.Charles, West Fargo, ND
January 3, 2026
Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped):
Childhood memory. Love theseSTEPHANIE, Fresno, CA
January 3, 2026
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Purely pleasure. They are fresh, flavorful and exactly what we were looking for.Gloria, Bloomington, IL
January 3, 2026
Reese's Pieces:
So good! I love Reese's and this is by far the cheapest place I know to get them!Crystal, Severn, MD
January 2, 2026
Fruit Marzipan:
I was very happy at the speedy delivery for this last minute stocking stuffer! My kids were so happy to see one of their favorites which is so hard to find! Thank you!Roberta, Lebanon, PA
January 2, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
The first piece, it took me back to 1977 and how each of us kids got to open the white candy dish and pick one whole piece of this candy. We waited all year for that moment. Such qreat memories!Tanya, Mesquite, TX
January 2, 2026
Candy Corn:
These are so good! Just be careful, they'll make you gain weight fastCrystal, Severn, MD
January 2, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Love this candy. It brings back memories of my childhoodStacy, Dickinson, ND
January 2, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I love this candy. Great flavor, fun shapes. 5 starsJulia, Jerome, ID
January 1, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Taste incredible, nice packaging. Brought them to work and everyone went crazy over them.Kevin, Atlanta, GA
January 1, 2026
Original Mike & Ike®:
Love Mike and Ike and this stuff is legit. So fresh that it took a day of leaving the bag open to believe it was the really Mike and Ike!Christine, Queen Creek, AZ
January 1, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
The kids loved the old fashioned hard candy, flavors were delicious!Lisa, Willow Street, PA
January 1, 2026
Good & Plenty:
I'm a Good and Plenty addict and this is premium stuff.Christine, Queen Creek, AZ
January 1, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
This candy was just awesome...... But more important, it took me back to when I was a child at my grandmothers....She always had this type of Christmas candy in the fancy bowl.... As young'uns we were allowed just one piece with permission granted.... Was a real tuff choice, but we always chose the correct piece to satisfy the cravings.... Thanks for the memories....Leroy, Burbank, WA
December 31, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Nostalgic for my family and very freshCarmen, Detroit, MI
December 31, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
This candy is just as I remember it as a child. Brings back a lot of memories. It was real good.Tammy, Tappahannock, VA
December 31, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
This was my favorite Christmas candy growing up. My Grandparents always had a bowl out for the holidays. This really brought back memories.Gail, North Royalton, OH
December 31, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Soft. So yummy. My husband loved them.Mary, AUGUSTA, GA
December 31, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Just like the candy I grew up with during the holidays!Liesl, North Vernon, IN
December 31, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Right on time, thank, I hope to enjoy thank you.Kim, Glenwood, IL
December 31, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Excellent soft marshmallows and crunchy sweet coconut!Kathleen, Kalispell, MT
December 31, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Good taste just like I had as a kid.Eddie, Albemarle, NC
December 30, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
You guys are the only one's that has this old fashion candy. QUALITY!!Sharon, Allen, TX
December 30, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I love them it's nostalgic and reminds me of my childhood Christmas favoriteEvelyn, Manchester, CT
December 30, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Sister said “nostalgic and delicious “Elizabeth, Hot Springs, AR
December 30, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
The candy brought back old Christmas memories … the best old fashion Christmas Candy yet!Dianne, Sikeston, MO
December 30, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Reminded family of Great grandmothers house.Elizabeth, Aiken, SC
December 30, 2025
Ribbon Candy:
You guys are the only ones who has the ribbon candy. QUALITY!!Sharon, Allen, TX
December 30, 2025
Peppermint Bark Bites:
I had to hide these from myself. They were so good.Barbara, Rifle, CO
December 29, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Have been looking for this type Christmas candy for years. No success The quality and taste are perfectSuzy, Owensboro, KY
December 29, 2025
Creme Drops:
It’s a candy my dad used to eat and I love it reminds me of himBernice, Jonesboro, GA
December 29, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Excellent brought back memories for me and my family.Fannie, Maple Heights, OH
December 29, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Had all of the pieces I was looking for.Mackenzie, Cornell, MI
December 29, 2025
Original Mike & Ike®:
Absolutely fabulous !!! Wakes up your tastebuds.Roberta, Chillicothe, OH
December 29, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
just like when i was a kidAnna, Essex Junction, VT
December 29, 2025
Original Mike & Ike®:
Just as I remember them from childhood, sweet and slightly chewy.Edward, Indianapolis, IN
December 29, 2025
Ribbon Candy:
Everyone was amazed I found the ribbon candy I GAVE IT TO MY KIDS AS PART OF THEIR GIFTDena, Victoria, TX
December 29, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Loved it haven't had that candy since I was young child.jimmie, Union City, TN
December 29, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Taste great! Just the right snack.Roberta, Chillicothe, OH
December 29, 2025
Hershey's Kisses®:
Love my kisses so I gave everyone a kissBernice, Jonesboro, GA
December 29, 2025
Peppermint Bark Bites:
the taste was very good, just the right amount of peppermint flavor.Gina, Lexington, KY
December 27, 2025
Ribbon Candy:
I was thrilled to see these these were my daughter's favorite when she was a kid she's an adult now and still loves them when I can get them. Thank you thank you for bringing back a bit of nostalgia to my family.Patricia, Reading, PA
December 26, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I'm still " chowing " down on these.Michael, Daytona Beach, FL
December 26, 2025
Candy Corn:
It doesn't have to be Halloween to enjoy this sweet snack. Just a few are are enough for a treat.Nancy, Philadelphia, PA
December 24, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
My favorite holiday candy. Reminds me of when I was a kid.Donna, El Cajon, CA
December 23, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Believe it or not I haven’t broken into these yet! I’m certain I will not be disappointed. The reason I’m leaving a review is that I double checked my overall bill just prior and I don’t have absolutely anything to complain about in that regards. Yes, expensive but so is my habit lol and you maintain the price is very nicely. Thank you.Patricia, Duluth, MN
December 23, 2025
Boyer's Mallo Cups:
Yummy as ever! Unfortunately, I eat them in bed and I get chocolate crumbs in bed, but I guess that’s on me.Patricia, Duluth, MN
December 23, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I've been eating old fashion Christmas candy since I was a little girl. I'm a Senior Citizen now and buy it every year. The taste is undescribable. Mm Mm GOODVickie, Monmouth Junction, NJ
December 22, 2025
