Old Time Candy Reviews
Our Customers' Reviews and Testimonials
Showing 1-100 of 9339.
Creme Drops:
These were sooo good! Bought them out of nostalgia and they didn’t disappoint.Nina, Jewett City, CT
December 7, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
Delicious, definitely! Quality, great. May be the best I’ve tasted. Thank you.Nan, Asheboro, NC
December 7, 2025
Boyer's Mallo Cups:
These were fresh and delicious. I can’t find them locally, so I’ll be buying more in the future.Melissa, Pounding Mill, VA
December 4, 2025
Peppermint Sticks:
You have always provided top quality products that not only are fresh, tasty and of top quality, but you also provide fast delivery. What's there not to love! You rock!Wendy, Winter Springs, FL
December 4, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Always had during the holidays when I was a kid.Margaret, Moses Lake, WA
December 3, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Reminds me of going to my Grandma's for Christmas when I was a little girl.Jennifer, Colorado Springs, CO
December 3, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Taste so very good I will order againSherry, Shorewood, WI
December 2, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Reminds me of Christmas pastAngeline, Perry Hall, MD
December 1, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Reminds me of the hard candy that my grandparents had out on their coffee table for the holidays.Lori, Granite City, IL
December 1, 2025
Good & Plenty:
Love Good & Plenty, but my Diabetes tolerates it.Richard, Temple City, CA
December 1, 2025
Peppermint Sticks:
Very perperminty and easy to bite into. Something I can get addicted to.Pamela, Elkridge, MD
December 1, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
So delicious, look forward to this time of year to order this!Belinda, Hudson, FL
November 30, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Good traditional Christmas candyCheryl, Ellijay, GA
November 29, 2025
Hershey's Nuggets Assortment:
Yummy and they are small when you just want a low calorie treatLinda, Port Saint Lucie, FL
November 28, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I loved this candy, reminded me of my childhood.Pamela, Roswell, GA
November 27, 2025
Charleston Chew:
You can never go wrong with a bag of Charleston chew, you definitely can’t eat just one or two. Very addicting!Pamela, Roswell, GA
November 27, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
Perfect blend and ratio of chocolate and peppermint … delish!Linda, Southport, NC
November 25, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Very yummy! Very soft marshmallows and yummy coconut exterior. Love love these marshmallow coconut toasties!!!!Cindy, Centreville, MI
November 25, 2025
Hot Tamales:
Always fresh and soft. If I buy them anywhere else, I'm usually disappointed. You've made me a Hot Tamale snobBarbara, Riverton, UT
November 25, 2025
Good & Plenty:
Other than the size being greatly reduced, the flavor is still goodGinger, Plainview, NY
November 25, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I BOUGHT THESE FOR SMALL GIFTS.Catherine, Millsboro, DE
November 25, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Some pieces are very large, but tasty.Mary, MONUMENT, CO
November 25, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
Peppermint bark has always been my ultimate favorite chocolate treat, and this was the best I've ever had! I also was pleased with the packaging.Mary, North Richland Hills, TX
November 24, 2025
Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped):
Second time we are buying this because it is not available in the supermarkets. It's a nice candy.Mona, Pennington, NJ
November 23, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Reminds me of years ago ChristmasCurtis, Beverly Hills, FL
November 23, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
Received this Peppermint Bark and immediately put it in the freezer so that we could eat it during the holidays. If it came from Nuts.com it is always good.Sandra, Ballwin, MO
November 23, 2025
Original Mike & Ike®:
Same quality and pricing of all their products.Charles, Fenton, MO
November 23, 2025
Original Mike & Ike®:
I love these sooooo much. Suddenly I become a kid again!Sheryl, Beverly Hills, MI
November 23, 2025
Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped):
Childhood favorite. It's the best snack. Recommend for all ages.Tracy, Chillicothe, OH
November 23, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
I love the dark chocolate! The taste is exactly what I wanted! It’s a holiday favorite.Kathleen, Huntley, IL
November 22, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Just a great childhood reminder. Love these.Ellen, Reedville, VA
November 22, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Excellent product and great valueJeffrey, Lincoln, NE
November 22, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
The best marshmallows I have ever tasted addictiveMervat, Schererville, IN
November 22, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
These taste so WONDERFUL! I was caught off guard by how thick they are! This is not “pop in your mouth to melt” peppermint chocolate candy! Just delicious!Trinity, Anderson, SC
November 22, 2025
Creme Drops:
Tastes just like the old fashioned chocolate drops I remember from my childhood.Frances, Lady Lake, FL
November 21, 2025
Ribbon Candy:
Like the size & taste. Just the right amount so you don't have to eat it for yearkatherine, Enfield, NH
November 21, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
Quintessential Holiday candy! Delicious and very fresh! Arrived super fast!MADONNA, Crest Hill, IL
November 20, 2025
Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped):
Perfect as a take-along treat.Joyce, Minden, NV
November 20, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Fresh and good mix of fruit flavors.Kathy, Jenks, OK
November 20, 2025
Bit-O-Honey:
Just like the old days!! Great hit with this! Will be back soonMarvinia, Atlanta, GA
November 20, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
It is a reminder of my happy childhood with my wonderful parents and family get togethers. Mom always had this candy sitting out for everyone the whole holiday season.Rose, Elkhart, IN
November 19, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Very good, brings back old memories.Toni, Evansdale, IA
November 18, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
This os about the only place I ca get these marshmallows and they are terrific. Thanks/Connie, payette, ID
November 18, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
They look good, but I'm using them on Christmas Eve. I'm assuming they'll taste good.Sheri, Brighton, MI
November 18, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
I normally order the milk chocolate peppermint bark from Williams Sonoma. I took a chance and will definitely be ordering more of this from you. Even with the dark chocolate it was the perfect blend of sweet and mint.Denise, Cape Coral, FL
November 18, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
Delicious. Not to Minty which I Love.Elizabeth, Staten Island, NY
November 18, 2025
Peppermint Bark:
Just yummy! Get it if you love peppermint and chocolate!Cathy, Russells Point, OH
November 18, 2025
