Old Time Candy Reviews

These are a favorite at our house! Love black licorice and the candy coating!

Excellent

My favorit.

Old reliable

Remind me of my child hood

My favorite candy for my candy jar. Not sticky and always fresh.

My favorite

Brachs are still better

Love these! Soft and the toasted coconut is so yummy!

These are always so good, I cannot get enough

Also an early Christmas gift.

We can never go wrong with smarties

good taste and pleasing

Early Christmas gift.

I only meant to eat a handful. Instead, I ate the whole bag. Good, even, cinnamon flavor. Not too spicy. I’m thinking of ordering more.

Not your normal Milk dud, a surprising center.

These taste good and are a great value, but they give me horrible diarrhea and I think I know why. Turns out the nuts.com version contains mineral oil and the original theater version doesn't. I can eat the name brand ones without any issues, but not these. I looked up the company that makes the originals online and compared their ingredients to the ingredients on the nuts.com version and there are several differences. Maybe it's just me, maybe it's not the mineral oil and it's some other ingredient. But I won't be trying them again, lol.

My absolute favorite. One of the best old fashioned candies you can get.

I’m so disappointed!!!! You advertised butter rum in your flavors and out of the 6 lbs, there was not 1 butter rum! False advertisement!!!!! Butter rum was my favorite. So disappointing.

tastes just like they did when I was a kid. Also nice to have a small size snack.

Addictive! Great sesame seed flavor, and it doesn't have a heavy sugary texture or taste.

Love these, especially if put in the fridge.

wonderful

Nice to get these Reese's Pieces any time because they are hard to find most of the time.

So fresh. Best cotton candy outside of the fair.

Nice that I can get this original peanut butter cup any time I want & it is always packed in a ice pack cooler

An old time favorite

I like the conversation hearts, they are one of my favorite product. I also noticed that the conversation hearts had a price change.

Pretty disappointed on the mixture of flavors. Received 3 chocolate, and 2 raspberry, the rest were butter rum, maple, etc.

These are great, remind me of when i was a kid.

A bite of heaven

taste of licorice

These are my one weakness of mine. I try not to buy them, but I always give in. Nice texture, they seem to melt in my mouth.

Great candy…(as always).

Sent to my sister on her Birthday. She loved the Candy Necklace. As a little girl growing up she always had these around her neck it seems. She enjoyed the nostalgia! So thank you. John C.

These are so very addictive! I love the strong vanilla flavor and the toasted coconut such a good combination.

Hershey is not the best chocolate but does satisfy a craving.

Just like the ones I got @ the movies Ya gotta try them

Old school! Lots of memories!

Love it!

This sesame candy brings back so many memories for me. I used to eat them when I was a child & am very happy you carry them. They are so tasty & have a perfect light crunch. Low sodium & low sugar is an added bonus.

So yummy

Love chocolate.

These have always been a favorite. I love being able to buy a better quantity of them.

Oh my! I can't tell you how much I love this pillowey soft marshmallow covered with toasty coconuts! It is so yummy that I have to stop myself from over indulging. If you live marshmallows and coconut, I suggest you give it a go! It's a little high in total carbs(including sugar) but worth it!

just love the flavor

Good. An old product, still good.

It's the same as the Good & Plenty sold in stores.

Taste like the old time candy we got as kids! They are great!

My all time favorite . Can't get enough plus they're not high calorie.

Thank you for the good service.

Delicious

Softest, freshest tastiest marshmallows ever; the only candy food I eat.

Yummy and very fresh

One of the best I have ever had

Great product!

I love these so I always buy several bags to last me and to share with friends.

They are excellent. My grandson loves them.

so good, reminds me of childhood!

Yummy

Good all year long

Excellent taste, texture and freshness.

Fresh, delicious and better than any other conversation hearts.

Awesome

satisfied my urge for caramel ... thankful these were smaller packs to kind of save me from myself ;-)

They were fresh and the guanity at a good price.

They were fresh and a good price.

Love them!

Awesome

As I remembered as a kid. I put them in the bottom of my cocoa mug with hot almond milk melting them. Yummmm

So fresh . They literally melt in your mouth.

Excellent quality and taste. The packaging kept everything from melting.

love them ordered 2 more bags

Fresh

great taste will order again

It goes without much ado that Good & Plenty is a fantastic candy treat. Best of all, Nuts.com delivers them with ultimate freshness.

Love them so much

love them i shared with my daughter

Very popular and great tasting!

LOVE these

They weren't bad, but I really wanted them to have more of a homemade taste but they were just like Kraft carmels you'd buy at a grocery store.

My wife's favorite, good price!

Very good!

Love these!!

Favorite

Thank you

My favorite! You guys have the best flavor caramels.

They taste like they have since they were first made. I love them

wish you had all chocolate ones too

Tasty and reliable.

fruity, fresh, very chewy

i’ve always been addicted to these things usually just buy a small box, but I splurged and bought more. it comes fresh sometimes you can’t say that when you buy a box

Best caramels!

I'll keep buying mallo cups until they or I no longer exist. i grew up with these. love them

Great

Good chew. Good taste.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Needs a bit more honey

Love chocolate and peanut butter

The best tasting products! And not found in any other place at this great price. I buy the toffees and jelly beans every month. And try other items .. never been disappointed.