Old Time Candy Reviews
Our Customers' Reviews and Testimonials
Showing 101-200 of 9815.
Peppermint Sticks:
King Leo Peppermint Sticks are the BEST! Nuts.com is the BEST! We just Ordered 80 Peppermint Sticks from Nuts.com!!!Michael, Clinton, MS
February 17, 2026
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
These were very fresh and I totally enjoyed them.5 starsNoreen, The Villages, FL
February 17, 2026
Candy Corn:
Taste, product quality. You just made me reach in the candy jar.Kelma, Elberon, VA
February 16, 2026
Good & Plenty:
Fresh and good tasting. A good old fashioned candy!Linda, Des Plaines, IL
February 15, 2026
Smarties:
I was obsessed with these so much I would grab a handful and they would be gone in no time. Very fresh and tastyDonna, Choctaw, OK
February 14, 2026
Conversation Hearts:
Yummy and fun, but some of the messages aren't clear. No biggie!!Elizabeth, Camp Hill, PA
February 13, 2026
Honey Sesame Crunch Bites (Wrapped):
Best ever. Stock up, they disappear fast.Carol, McHenry, IL
February 11, 2026
Bit-O-Honey:
wonderful taste of childhood. (also loved by adults ! )martha, Elmwood, TN
February 10, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Everything was just right. Thank you.robert, Worton, MD
February 9, 2026
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Very good worth the money will be ordering more very soonTerrie, Strongsville, OH
February 8, 2026
Bit-O-Honey:
I believe I bought one or two of these bags. They were good but could use more nuts for sure.Susan, Apple Valley, CA
February 8, 2026
Peanut Chews:
Loved the peanut chews. There were so yummy and fresh. I see they are on sale but am debating about buying them again because I liked them so much that I probably ate too many at one time for my prediabetes condition. I think the sale price might just nudge me to reorder them.Susan, Apple Valley, CA
February 8, 2026
Charleston Chew:
Loved these little candy bars. They were fresh and yummy. The only problem was that I'd eat way too many of these, alternating them with the Peanut Chews. They were just too good to resist. Perfect with a cold glass of milk! I'd recommend and I'm sure I'll buy again.Susan, Apple Valley, CA
February 8, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Brought back memories. UMichelle, North Smithfield, RI
February 7, 2026
Caramels:
These have a mild taste and much softer than a regular caramel. Not the same.Pauline, Sterling Heights, MI
February 6, 2026
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
This product was fresh and delicious.David, Dover Plains, NY
February 6, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I LOVE THIS OLD FASHIONED CHRISTMAS CANDY ALL YEAR LONG.Pamela, Braddock, PA
February 5, 2026
Boyer's Mallo Cups:
I haven't had a Mallo Cup in a very long time; I was surprised to find it hereJANET, Philadelphia, PA
February 5, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Reminds me of my grandparents. It's just good old fashion candy.Latrina, Hewitt, TX
February 5, 2026
Candy Corn:
Brought them for my daughter she loves candy cornMark, Rutherfordton, NC
February 4, 2026
Conversation Hearts:
Softer texture than the classic convo heart, but just as tasty.Laura, Scituate, MA
February 3, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Good flavors but they were very broken up.Heather, Punta Gorda, FL
February 3, 2026
Necco Wafers:
Completely fresh! These seem like I ke the are fresh out of the factoryAlan, Thompsons Station, TN
February 3, 2026
Caramels:
Just not as good as krafts caramels. Evwrything else i ordered was very good.Edward, Macon, GA
February 2, 2026
Bit-O-Honey:
This is always been my favorite candy.I'm so happy you have it.I'm an old lady and I love it.Thank youPhylis, Ontario, CA
February 1, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I bought for the memories but I wouldn't buy again. Too many broken pieces at the bottom of the bag.Claire, Bethlehem, PA
February 1, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I bought the hard candy as an occasional treat and it it doesn’t disappoint.Billy, Des Arc, AR, AR
January 31, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
i enjoyed them but som was broken upSHEILA, Atco, NJ
January 30, 2026
Peanut Chews:
Never bought these before, but love them. Will buy again!Velda, Raleigh, NC
January 29, 2026
Conversation Hearts:
you guys only carry these all the time, I love thatJuanita, Arlington, TX
January 28, 2026
Creme Drops:
These are pretty sweet. They are not a soft cream texture like true butter creams are, but will satisfy a sugar craving quickly.Denise, Collegeville, PA
January 28, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Was best Christmas candy we have tried!Angela, Hamler, OH
January 28, 2026
Conversation Hearts:
Love these, they don't have that chaulky Necco tasteRich, Manorville, NY
January 28, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
These are very nostalgic because they all have a weird peppermint taste when you put them in your mouth but they’ll be grape or orange. Still not sure why you mix peppermint in with fruit flavors cause the peppermint takes over but I love it lolKelley, Hereford, AZ
January 26, 2026
Fruit Marzipan:
These are by far the best. So fresh and tasty!Karen, Apache Junction, AZ
January 22, 2026
Candy Corn:
There's nothing better than good, fresh and plenty of it, candy!Brigid, Port Charlotte, FL
January 22, 2026
Ribbon Candy:
This was picked for my granddaughter! It was a Christmas HIT for her!Katherine, Brookeland, TX
January 21, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
It tastes like childhood hopes & dreams ! My package came about two days earlier than excepted. Which is great ! There's no candy, especially old fashioned (that tastes like ribbon candy but better) out there quite like this. You guys are amazing ! It was the perfect birthday gift for my Mama. It was actually my birthday that was coming up. But, to see my Mama smile & giggle like a child on Christmas Day was all that I wanted for a birthday present. To see her smile was the greatest gift I could give myself. Thank you, for making that dream come true. You will definitely have lifelong customers out of my family.James, Skipwith, VA
January 20, 2026
Peppermint Bark:
Every family member LOVED this! Will be ordering again as soon as it's available again!Ken, Seattle, WA
January 20, 2026
Candy Corn:
Great candy corn. I love it all year around and not just in the Fall so it’s great to know that I can order whenever that craving strikes and keep a full supply!Jacqueline, Marietta, GA
January 20, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Didn’t taste like the candy I had as a kid. It seemed that the candy taste all the same no matter what pieces you had.Renee, Rock Springs, WY
January 19, 2026
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I've had a craving for Christmas candy and it's tough to find. Certain pieces are better than others, but I enjoyed the whole bagJohn, Kennewick, WA
January 19, 2026
