Old Time Candy Reviews
Our Customers' Reviews and Testimonials
Showing 401-500 of 9565.
Smarties:
The greats (nieces and nephews), love these, so I like having them around. Truth be told, I like them too.Joan, Milwaukee, WI
October 26, 2025
Conversation Hearts:
I love these. It's really great that I can buy these all year round, not just Valentine's Day time. Great value for money. They are yummy!!Marty, New Llano, LA
October 25, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I ordered this item with my candy corn. Haven’t had Old Fashion Christmas Candy in a long time. While eating a piece it brings back many holiday memories. Very fresh tasting and love the packaging it ships in.Cheryl, Lexington, KY
October 21, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
The very best melt in your mouth flavor . Creamy good !Lynn, Seminole, FL
October 21, 2025
Candy Corn:
I order from NUTS. Com mostly due to sales or Holidays. Candy Corn my favorite for Halloween. Tastes fresh and I love the heavy packages the orders are shipped in.Cheryl, Lexington, KY
October 21, 2025
Hershey's Miniatures:
Been enjoying.these for many years; can count on them for their taste stays the same, have no fears !Fran, Bellingham, MA
October 21, 2025
Original Mike & Ike®:
Every time I order something it's fresh. It does not taste stale!Sharon, Southgate, MI
October 20, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
memories of my great aunt philena arriving with a box of these!Mary, Kennett Square, PA
October 19, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Im not much into christmas candies but my parents loved these and they really enjoyed them alot.Thaddeus, Stebbins, AK
October 17, 2025
Peppermint Sticks:
These are good peppermints...really didnt expect them to be like chalk like texture. Hard on the outside then somewhat soft on the inside...but still love the peppermint flavor.Thaddeus, Stebbins, AK
October 17, 2025
Hershey's Miniatures:
This item is one of my favorites! Excellent chocolate miniature bars, with flavors that really please my palate. If you are hungry for wonderful chocolate, but don't want a full-size bar, this assortment will make you sigh with delight!Carol, Traer, IA
October 17, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
Love, love, love nuts!!! Shipping is amazingly fast and their products are the BEST!!!! If only all companies performed as well as nuts……..Cheryl, Cincinnati, OH
October 15, 2025
Conversation Hearts:
Well, here goes another review for these conversation hearts… I love these and I know a lot of people don’t but I do. Nuts.com’s conversation hearts are different from the ones you get in the grocery store or drugstore. They are much better!Teresa, Westminster, CO
October 13, 2025
Candy Corn:
This is our favorite Fall candy dish go to. Paired with salted peanuts, it is so good. Thrilled to find it in a pound package and at a great price.Melissa, Lees Summit, MO
October 13, 2025
Original Mike & Ike®:
Love getting them so quick, and great tasteJuanita, Arlington, TX
October 10, 2025
Conversation Hearts:
Love an item I can get even after valentine day. I eat a few every night while watching tvJuanita, Arlington, TX
October 10, 2025
Hot Tamales:
Some times you need a strong cinnamon flavored candy.Jane, Cedar Rapids, IA
October 9, 2025
Hot Tamales:
Have not ate yet but I am sure they will be fantasticRobert, Hanover Twsp, PA
October 2, 2025
Creme Drops:
As good as any premium cream cups costing 3 times as much. Delicious, thick, dark chocolate coating with smooth creamy filling. Highly recommend will buy againRobert, Philadelphia, PA
October 1, 2025
Boyer's Mallo Cups:
Almost like I remember them from 50 years ago, maybe the quality has slipped a tad bit, or maybe my age/taste buds.... the chocolate does not seem as thick or as tasty/quality as I remember it, and the mallo not as vanilla tasting - but decent enough. Hint of the coconut pieces here and there. These are individual servings per wrapped candy. The packaging and packing as well as the shipping speed was excellent!!! :)Marilyn, Glen Ellyn, IL
September 30, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
I love that you have the old time candy. So what about the lollipops that where Carmel swirls with pink mixed in. Or the old cherry gum balls. Old school is awesome.Kelly, Las Vegas, NV
September 30, 2025
Caramels:
Lovely flavor, don’t stick to your teeth too badly, and they are individually wrapped which keeps them fresh.Lee Ann, Santa Fe, NM
September 30, 2025
Peanut Chews:
These are so good and so hard to find. Was so happy to see that you had them.Laura, Brooklyn, CT
September 29, 2025
Good & Plenty:
Very tasty licorice treat. I just wish that when coupons were offered they didn’t have such a quick expiration date. Let mine expire because I didn’t need to buy anymore in such a short period of time.Angelica, Albuquerque, NM
September 29, 2025
Good & Plenty:
It is hard to find Good & Plenty in stores anymore. Nuts has it and they are very fresh and yummy!Rosemarie, Buffalo, NY
September 28, 2025
Smarties:
I ordered these for my son in law cause this is one of his favorite candies.Elly, San Jose, CA
September 27, 2025
Reese's Mini Peanut Butter Cups:
Yum. Like the flavor of the peanut butter is so good.Elly, San Jose, CA
September 27, 2025
Candy Corn:
Husband and I like to mix candy corn and peanuts, but most of what you can find in the store is made in another country. We were glad to find these made in the USA!Rachael, Louisville, KY
September 27, 2025
Caramels:
Tastes like the real thing did 30 yrs ago and Not artificial.Robert, York, PA
September 27, 2025
Charleston Chew:
The hose chews are the greatest n so wonderful.Elly, San Jose, CA
September 27, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
WOW great memory as a kid growing up....G.D.Helton, Swannanoa, NC
September 26, 2025
Reese's Mini Peanut Butter Cups:
Just for a tiny little sweet treat. Always goos.Bonnie, Brooklyn, NY
September 22, 2025
Good & Plenty:
What can I say? I've been eating Good & Plenty for decades.Regina, Pittsburgh, PA
September 22, 2025
Original Mike & Ike®:
Good fruity flavor, a favorite of my grand kidsBetty, Chandler, AZ
September 22, 2025
Boyer's Mallo Cups:
Another one from my past. Tasted the same as I remember.Kenneth, Wolfe City, TX
September 18, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Nothing!! Love them just the way they are!! Yummy!!!Mary, Philadelphia, PA
September 18, 2025
Smarties:
This was my "Go-To" treat for my child for years. Now I get to treat the grandkids.Mary, Holt, MI
September 17, 2025
Candy Corn:
This candy corn is by far the freshest candy corn I have EVER eaten. It tastes delicious and unfortunately is gonna be gone way too soon. I will just have to order more before the season is over. I'm not kidding! Best I've ever eaten.Cindy, Canton, MI
September 17, 2025
Smarties:
One of my favorites from MANY years ago. I always used to say, after you had a Dum Dum lollipop, you HAD to eat a roll of Smarties to counteract!!!Susan, Mays Landing, NJ
September 16, 2025
Marshmallow Coconut Toasties:
Too soft. I usually buy them from other companies, having the consistency in size and texture as regular marshmallows.Edwin, Granville, NY
September 14, 2025
Charleston Chew:
Brought back childhood memories, The chocolate and marshmallow combination can not be beat with this.Eva, Greenville, MI
September 10, 2025
Candy Necklaces (Wrapped):
This was a gift and 2 kids plus an adult loved them.Sandra, Hartford, NY
September 9, 2025
Candy Corn:
This is excellent quality candy corn. They are a little smaller than the candy corn I'm used to, but they have excellent flavor.David, Mexico, MO
September 9, 2025
Smarties:
I love the sweet and sour taste and I will definitely buy morePamela, Harrison, GA
September 6, 2025
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy:
This was the wrong choice on my part, where they did remind me of Grandma I put them in the wrong container and they stuck together... however I will buy more around ChristmasCarolyn, La Crosse, WI
September 4, 2025
Candy Corn:
I love candy corn and these are very fresh and taste delicious.Margaret, Brooklyn, NY
September 3, 2025
