Salt Water Taffy Reviews

Great flavors, soft ans chewy. I ordered this for my daughter but every one keeps sneaking them because they are so good.

Lots of pink ones but no licorice.

My favorite.

Wonderful flavor!! Reminds me of my childhood! So fresh!

Individual flavors are flavor packed. Yum.

Oh my these are sooooo good. I have to limit how many I eat otherwise I would have the bag gone in one sitting.

Absolutely delicious! Would definitely order again.

It was very tangy and sticky.

This is the best sugar free taffy I have ever tasted. I highly recommend this taffy for anyone on a low-sugar diet. You can't tell it from the normal taffy.

Yummy good

The taffy is really good, they melt in your mouth, smooth.

NOT SUGAR FREE WITH 12 GRAM OF SUGAR LISTED ON THE BAG

old fashion treat

First time I have tried this sugar free item. There were favorites within this bag of course. One was the taste of red cinnamon candies and the other was licorce delight. Of course since these were my favorites the others were OK in my taste buds. Wish you would have one flavor per bag that you can choose. I would get one of each of my favorites.

Sorry I bought these--almost non-existent flavor.

My daughter absolutely love the flavors. Especially the cinnamon!

Unlike other taffy I've had. Much too gummy.

Old favorite of mine!

very intense concentrated flavors...very enjoyable!

Wonderful flavors!! Reminds me of my childhood summers. Can’t eat just one! These are such a great value. I always order multiple bags.

Too Bad this taffy was terrible, and I do like Taffy. The taste was too sweet, and artificial chemical tasting. I would not buy or recommend.

Great flavor and good consistency.

I only ate a few & in combination with a few gummies they caused GI problems...probably due to the sweetner

very good

so soft and chewey

very mediocre

I love the flavor and product was fresh.

Nice and sweet tasting. Lots of different flavors to choose from. A little bit sticky.

They were okay!

Can’t go wrong with salt water taffy.

great flavors...

Texture was excellent. Freshness, always a big problem with taffy, was spot-on. But flavor was a bit acidic, instead of the "smoothness" I prefer. I think it came from too much flavor added. Happened with many of the fruit flavors. The chocolates and vanillas, on the otherhand, were great!

Just like I remember! Great shipping!

Been years since I have had Salt Water Taffy, these brought back a lot of memories of happier times.

Love the flavors.

It was great but some of my guests expressed a desire for peanut butter taffy. Maybe next year.

Can't keep my neighbor keep s eating it

Delicious, soft, just enough sweetness even though it's sugar free. Flavors are a nice selection.

Best sugar free taffy

Delicious, sweet, amazingly flavorful! Watch out 'coz it sticks to your teeth! I usually only have 1 to 3 pieces at a time, due to the sugar alcohols, but it is good time spent enjoying these yummy sugar free sweet treats!

Strong flavors and nice colors.

Everyone likes these

I did not care for these

I start with 1, and always end up with 5. Thy're just that good.

This taffy is the best around.

The best I"ve ever had

Present. A real favorite of the person who's getting hem.

Brings back lots of memories

I bought these for my mother, she loves saltwater taffy all year round.

They all tasted similar......poor flavor.

what we expected

Love it ,I’m into Taffy right now,

Just ok. Some seemed to taste artificial.

Family enjoy water taffy, a good snack. Thanks!

No the best sugar free taffy I've tasted

Delicious.

wasn't sugar free

It were so so delicious & tasty to

Really, really good.

Not Hardly any True Flavoring. To sugary, & Tangy. Sorry.

Really yummy. Don't stick to your teeth--hooray!

Stale.

Very Sticky

Not really much flavor. Lots of color, but I'm used to green taffy tasting like lime and red tasting of cherry or strawberry. They really all tasted pretty much the same.

Liked these, love that there was no licorice flavor, but some of the flavors kind of blended together.

My husband loves these. I include at least 2 pounds of these with EVERY order! Sometimes the salt water taffy

The worst taffy Ai have ever had. There was kind of a metallic taste.

Deliciousness. Totally unbeatable.

Fresh and tasty but sticky. Stuck to my teeth.

sinful indulgence

Always great!

My family likes the salt water taffy but to me I miss not having peppermint,licorice,orange cream and peanut butter flavors.

Another excellent sugar free snack.

Pretty standard, easy to chew and easy to binge. Favors could be made more intense but, of course, no nutritive value.

This taffy is not Taffy Town brand, like the single flavor bags sold on this site. This taffy is too sweet and has the consistency of Starburst (very sugary and not fluffy, like taffy should be). The flavors are not distinct and just taste bad. I couldn’t eat more than a few pieces and gave the rest away to some kids (who are not picky). This is one of the worst taffies I have ever tried.

Could be softer.

Taffy is nice and soft also great flavors.

Tastes as real as a full sugar type

Love the different flavors, nice fresh and delightfully chewy.

Excellent!

It is really good says my husband who is diabetic and switching from high sugar treats to sugar free.

Tasty combination. I was going to order the plain vanilla taffy, but I thought what the heck? I’m glad I tried the combo flavored taffy.

Fresh

Hard, little flavor, and sticks to teeth.

Fresh

Good flavors.

Everytime we are in Maine we always stop and pickup some taffy. Will no longer be doing that. The Salt Water Taffy from Nuts.com is sooooo much better. Both in taste and freshness. Very satisfied.

The taffy is extremely hard.

For my granddaughter at college

The best

Great!

Reminds me of being at the ocean on vacation. Wonderful flavors.

It's salt water taffy why wouldn't it get 5 stars.

Love them

Soft and delicious!

Very good.

Very nice.

soft and does not stick to your teeth

So absolutely yummy good

Awfully good. Better than Atlantic City taffy! Creamy and gooey soft.