Old Time Candy Reviews

I grew up eating Good & Plenty. I still crave them. Now I get them by the pound.

I will be ordering more of this type of candy in the future. If you have other candy varieties can you please display!

Husbands favorite and I thought this was a special treat instead of jelly beans

They’re the best toasted marshmallows

would like more butter rum. but still no problem.

I love my chocolate

Softer tan usual. Wonderful

They are smaller than I remember but they dont last long

So yummy. Takes me back. You have so many items I have missed for a long time.

Who doesn’t love Reese’s

Tastes like I remember. So good and fresh!

I can't keep the bowl of these full...my husband's favorite...

My very favorite candy. They are always so fresh and yummy. The order and delivery is the best. Always arrives on time and in perfect condition. Bravo !!

A little difference in flavor, but fresh.

These were given to little children. What kid doesn't like suckers.

The best chocolate nuggets ever! Just two nuggets satisfies that craving but three nuggets are even better

The marshmallow is soft with just the right amount of coconut shavings

very fresh tasting

A big hit at our house!

Nothing better than a Bit of Honey. Absolutely love these!!

Flavor good but marshmallow always leaks and makes a mess.

Add flavor. Sometimes funky aftertaste.

Great size.

Needs Double thickness of chocolate covering.

I love them

Good old fashion taste

These are very soft, which we all liked. I wish that they were not all the same flavor, they're a little bland. Overall, I would buy them again.

These are such a treat! We sued to get these as children and these are just as I remember them.

Love them,they remind me of when I was a kid with my grandparents

Not bad for me, but my mother absolutely loves these. She says the caramel has the perfect consistency.

Love them,a flash from the past

always fresh and soft

I bought these for two children and one of them loved them and ate most of the ones I brought over. Leaving only a couple for his brother.

Good as I remembered them from like 30 years ago. The tastes match the flavor noted on the wrapper and are semi-soft, just how I like them.

Perfect, controlled portion sized. They are a good tasting chocolate candy.

Absolutely rich and creamy

Awesome...as always!!!❤

Awesome...as always!!!❤

Have ordered these 3 times now. Delicious!

My granddaughter love these! I like the big bag so I can give her some as a small treat or for a reward.

They are awesome, fresh

I ordered the cream drops to see if they are like what I remembered. Yes they are. ]】]]

Awesome...as always!!!❤

These are ordered for my mother of the young age of 93. She just loves Reese’s and I just love your dependable order delivery !

Too many licorice pieces.

These are for me,a childhood favorite!

Very fresh soft toffee.

Always good and fresh

YUM!

The "conversations " are cute. Love the flavors

Awesome

My favorite old fashioned candy!

We love these crunchy, sweet little tidbits of sesame!!!

can never go wrong with HERSHEY

Yummy...brings back great childhood memories!

I got these for a friend because she loves the 'store' ones, she let me taste, these are FAR superior to the ones we had as children=YUM!

They were fresh and not too hard. I didn't get a chance to eat many, someone beat me to them, but l was pleasantly surprised at the quality.

Very food flavors!

Good taste but you need an instruction manual to get the candy unwrapped.

I bought these for my husband for valentines day... He LOVED them and so did I. They are simply delicious!

Hard to unwrap of course!

Were good, I liked them.

This is okay. Very sweet, wish I could taste more of the flavors rather than just sugar.

I love it

Always fresh. Not at all like the box of candy you might buy in a store. Kids love em.

Hard to find treat. Another favorite.

I Love these Candy Harts Awesome, a must buy.

Miss not having coconut in the mix

My grandson loved them!

The best, always fresh. Thank you.

love these...they are portable

My absolute favorite!

Was disappointed there were no butter rum flavor

I find the caramels very tasty however they are very challenging to unwrap.

We order the Assorted Toffees often. We like how fresh they are and they taste delicious.

The best!!

Very fresh and tasty

I don't remember the original ones being a bit sour.

just what i was looking for.

What's not to love about Mike & Ike? The original is ALWAYS the best! Love, love 'em!

This is usually what I buy. Seems you can’t find this type of candy anywhere else. I grew up eating this type of candy at Christmas.

I love peppermint. My grandfather used to keep peppermint sticks, cinnamon sticks and Horehound candy sticks all the time when I was a kid.

Old fashioned wrapped Hershey Kisses will always be a favorite!

Yummy

Love, love love these! Maybe cut down on the strawberry ones and add more toffee and chocolate or even let people choose their own flavors!

This is the best!

I make treat bags for all my friends and these are great! I add cinnamon dots and assorted nuts, yours of course, and everyone is happy!!

Orered several times now

I love the conversation hearts anyway, but these had a flavor that I had not tasted before. The flavor was delicious and I enjoyed every piece of the heart. I will be ordering the hearts again because I love the hearts and wish that I could purchase them year round.

My husband loves these and they are always fresh.

Love licorice

love them

I got them to make smores. I’ve now hidden the bag and they are my new snack favorite.

My husband loved these candy hearts, I will definitely order continually.

Regular re-order for years - the marshmallows are so good!

Love these.

My favorites.

mmmmmmmm

Family favorites.

Love peanut butter cups!