Old Time Candy Reviews

Delightfully soft inside, not hard like a lot of convenience store ones can be. Our grandsons have discovered a fondness for these little gems.

Absolutely love these. Our middle eastern shop closed so have really been missing these, so glad I can get them from you.

I love these little gems! Very fresh and tasty!

Just love these hard to find bites!

Usually, these are delicious. But my most recent delivery was very stale.

I send to my air force grandson in California. Out of my 2 orders the only thing that wasn't up to par was the carmel corn. His 3 favorites are reese's p/b cups , original beefy jerky & cashews.Keep up the good work!! KLOTT

A family favorite!

The best I've ever had!!

DELICIOUS!!!

The BEST!!!!! Will be my winter staple

The cream drops were old and stale.

Just like Lay’s potato chips you can’t just eat one!

Sooo disappointing. They were stale and hard. Obviously didn't come from nuts.com but I sugget you not carry them any more. $9.99 a box that we basically thru out.

This is one of my all time favorites.

I love them!!!

Very good flavor. And fresh

great

Brings back memories.

I absolutely love these. It was like bringing my childhood back.

I loved these as a kid. I had to order them. Still love them. I will be ordering them again.

Haven't tried them yet but I'm sure they will be good!

Do not taste like milk duds at all

Very sweet just not a lot of distinctive flavors.

Fruity tasting and very addictive!

Love these!!! Hard to stop eating them!!!

Santa Claus always brought us Creme Drops for Christmas. They still remind me of the fun and exciting time I had. These are one of my comfort foods.

Very good flavoring & great assortment of the flavors!

I couldn't find Candy Corn very easy. You made it easy to find. Love you Candy. How about The Maple Bun candy bar? I would love to get some!! Thank you!!

Just the way I remember really good

Too good, can’t eat just one

Just like when a kid

Unique flavors

Is this what non stale G&P are supposed to be?

Very good

It all tastes the same..a few different flavors detected but mostly the same..will not buy again.

Love them

Children love these and the variety offered. Thank you

My grandson found my stash. Now we love them together.

The cream was so soft and good and the chocolate was very tasty and not hard and crumbly.

You won't be able to eat just one.

Can’t go wrong with classic!

My favorite old fashion candy

Love them.

Good

Amazing!

We love marzipan but finding it can be a challenge, particularly when it isn’t Christmas time. I was delighted to find out that you carry it. I got it for my husband as a valentine gift. It arrived fresh and tasty. The traditional fruit shapes are very attractive. It made a special gift that we’re sure to reorder soon.

Best toffee I have ever had! Will be ordering again, would like to try more of your flavors:)

Omg takes me back to my childhood! Amazing!

Great taste

I'm more of a soft caramel, these are a little chewy for me. Flavor is good, just not my favorite type, personal preference

How can you go wrong with Good and Plenty. They are awesome.

They are hard to find. The ones from your company are the best

Always so fresh and chewy. Much better than the brand I used to buy at the grocery store.

absolutely loved loved these

Just can’t stop eating it!

Not much of a coconut taste. Will not purchase again

Love them

Excellent

We lOvE these Good & Plenty's! Fresh, and a nice, big pack!

These things are addicting. Very fresh.

I loved them

Different flavors from my last order was an unexpected and nice surprise.

old fashioned candy i love, gave a little nostalgia to my grands

They were a birthday gift for my granddaughter; they are also a favorite of mine.

Still delicious! This old school treat was a great find. Loved sharing with family. Honey, taffy goodness.

I like the variety of flavors and that the toffee isn't super sticky

Just as good or better when I had this when I was younger, fresh and packed well

Licorice is one of my favorites! These are soooo good!

Great cookie. I’ve ordered these before and am very satisfied with these delicious cookies. Thank you!

My husband loved these! You can’t find them anywhere except for another online store but it was stale and stuck together. These were fresh!

My second time ordering these. Love!!

Excellent

looking along time to find. had them when I was child.

I love these, delicious

Individual flavors of Toffees really came thru. Soft and chewy.

No milk duds like original... no carmel flavor ... too much chocolate..

Delicious and addictive.

Great taffy

Marzipan didn't taste fresh to me.

It's for my daughter's Valentines presents. Hasn't been opened yet but everything is always good from you guys.

Peppermint bark is my most Favorite thing ever!!!

These are beautiful. Have yet to use for making gifts but if they taste as good as they look....

Eating some right now! YUM! Reminds me of my childhood!

I couldn't stop eating them, gave me a stomach ache, lol.

Favorite since 1965

Theses are very creamy. Theses brought back alot of memories

They made a neat gift

Delicious

My favorites.

Wife is in7th Heaven!

Wonderful, but would like a few more flavors.

It was fun just ordering everything. Reminds me of a great store down on the Lower Eastside. Thanks for the experience.

It brings back old memories from child hood can't get enough

Appearance good, flavored so so.

If something is called black it should be black. Big disappointment.

OMG! Delicious!!! I need to order more!!!

They were hard. Not 3àsy to chew. Very disappointed ☹️.

It’s so hard to fine thes anywhere else!

Love these as a child

So good. I loved them.