Old Time Candy Reviews

My favorite old fashion candy

Can’t go wrong with classic!

Love them.

Omg takes me back to my childhood! Amazing!

Good

Amazing!

We love marzipan but finding it can be a challenge, particularly when it isn’t Christmas time. I was delighted to find out that you carry it. I got it for my husband as a valentine gift. It arrived fresh and tasty. The traditional fruit shapes are very attractive. It made a special gift that we’re sure to reorder soon.

Best toffee I have ever had! Will be ordering again, would like to try more of your flavors:)

I'm more of a soft caramel, these are a little chewy for me. Flavor is good, just not my favorite type, personal preference

They are hard to find. The ones from your company are the best

Great taste

How can you go wrong with Good and Plenty. They are awesome.

Always so fresh and chewy. Much better than the brand I used to buy at the grocery store.

Not much of a coconut taste. Will not purchase again

absolutely loved loved these

Just can’t stop eating it!

Love them

Excellent

We lOvE these Good & Plenty's! Fresh, and a nice, big pack!

These things are addicting. Very fresh.

I loved them

old fashioned candy i love, gave a little nostalgia to my grands

Different flavors from my last order was an unexpected and nice surprise.

Still delicious! This old school treat was a great find. Loved sharing with family. Honey, taffy goodness.

They were a birthday gift for my granddaughter; they are also a favorite of mine.

I like the variety of flavors and that the toffee isn't super sticky

Just as good or better when I had this when I was younger, fresh and packed well

Licorice is one of my favorites! These are soooo good!

Great cookie. I’ve ordered these before and am very satisfied with these delicious cookies. Thank you!

My husband loved these! You can’t find them anywhere except for another online store but it was stale and stuck together. These were fresh!

My second time ordering these. Love!!

Excellent

Individual flavors of Toffees really came thru. Soft and chewy.

looking along time to find. had them when I was child.

No milk duds like original... no carmel flavor ... too much chocolate..

I love these, delicious

Delicious and addictive.

Marzipan didn't taste fresh to me.

Great taffy

It's for my daughter's Valentines presents. Hasn't been opened yet but everything is always good from you guys.

Peppermint bark is my most Favorite thing ever!!!

These are beautiful. Have yet to use for making gifts but if they taste as good as they look....

Eating some right now! YUM! Reminds me of my childhood!

I couldn't stop eating them, gave me a stomach ache, lol.

Favorite since 1965

They made a neat gift

Delicious

Wife is in7th Heaven!

Theses are very creamy. Theses brought back alot of memories

My favorites.

Wonderful, but would like a few more flavors.

It was fun just ordering everything. Reminds me of a great store down on the Lower Eastside. Thanks for the experience.

It brings back old memories from child hood can't get enough

Appearance good, flavored so so.

It’s so hard to fine thes anywhere else!

Awesome

So good. I loved them.

OMG! Delicious!!! I need to order more!!!

They were hard. Not 3àsy to chew. Very disappointed ☹️.

If something is called black it should be black. Big disappointment.

Love these as a child

Delish! Perfect size yummy little treats.

Very good-TY

Just what I was looking for.

loved the peppermint taste!

Receiving these as a free gift made them that much better!

Perfect.

They were delicious. This I will order again

Fresh, great taste.

It tastes just like when I was younger.

always delicious!

Excellent, exactly what I was looking for

Delicious and fresh

Super FRESH!!! 1000% better than Brach's!

This quickly went to my favorites list. There is something about fresh, handmade marshmallows. They have a soft, melt-in-your mouth quality which commerical marshmallows just don't have. The coconut provides just enough crunch and they aren't overly sweet. One caveat - I could easily go through a bag. I really work to ration these out when I buy them or I end up eating too many.

This is the first time I ordered these and they did not disappoint! And they sure took me back to my childhood!

I thought it was fine, but m y daughter (47) thought it was great.

These taste just like candy corn used to taste! The candy corn that you can buy now in the stores just taste wierd! But these have that unique candy corn flavor that is so satisfying and good!

These taste rich and "caramely" with a sweet flavor that isn't available anymore! They are wonderful! Much better than Godiva's caramels!

Another item that is just like my Grandmother bought for me! It has the same honey nutty flavor as it did in the 1950's. My husband likes these too.

Chocolate covered nougat that is so sweet! I remember it well and have loved it for years!

They were loved by all! Thank you

This candy is as good as ever with that tangy licorice filling!

I really enjoy good candy corn thank you

Excellent. Look forward to the end of the year for this treat.

Stocking stuffer for the candy lover! He was impressed!

Many reorders bring back my childhood! I love these little candies!

1st time for the grandkids to receive - initially thought they were HUGE smarties, but quickly learned they are better!

These are always a Holiday favorite. The whole family always looks for the dish with these.

Perfect! I will order often and definitely every Nov through Dec

Delicious toffees! Great flavors and fresh tasting. The texture is really nice and smooth. I’m enjoying all the flavors and wish there were even more!

Awesome!! Everybody enjoyed them but another one of my nephews got the bulk of them and will now get these in his stocking

Another one of my all time favorite candies.

Freshest I've had!

Just the way they're supposed to taste .!

Milk duds were few and far between but tasty as I remember.

My husband tried these delicious treats and decided they were a worthy Christmas candy. He enjoyed the thick chocolate covered with a soothing peppermint flavored coating.

Was expecting a cookie base but this was even better!

The peppermint sticks are soft and have an amazing peppermint flavor!

can't find these easily anymore. glad you stock them