Skip to main content
FREE shipping on orders over $59!
Main Content

old time candy

value
chocolate
type
flavor
tags
166 results

French Burnt Peanuts

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(1638)

Peanut Brittle

$6.99/lb
$6.64/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(1654)
Best Seller

Gourmet Fruit Slices

$10.99/lb
$10.44/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(2000)

Dark Chocolate Almond Bark

$10.99
$10.44
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
8oz bag
(1789)

Peanut M&M's®

$6.99/lb
$6.64/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(1153)

Milk Chocolate Almond Bark

$9.99
$9.49
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
8oz bag
(971)

Orange Slices

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(1165)

Caramel Creams

$7.99/lb
$7.59/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(1475)

Salt Water Taffy

$6.99/lb
$6.64/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(999)

Gumdrops

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(1057)

Black Australian Licorice

$7.99/lb
$7.59/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(1519)

Liquorice Allsorts

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(1080)

Bit-O-Honey

$6.99/lb
$6.64/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(1082)

Heath® Candy Bars

$9.99/lb
$9.49/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(848)

Butterscotch Candy

$3.99/lb
$3.79/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(585)

Cherry Slices

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(871)

Soft Peppermint Puffs

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(623)

Root Beer Barrels

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(748)

Wintergreen Lozenges

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(562)

Jelly Belly 49 Flavors

$10.99/lb
$10.44/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(876)

Marshmallow Coconut Toasties

$6.99
$6.64
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
9oz container
(689)

Spearmint Leaves

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(966)

M&M's®

$7.99/lb
$7.59/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(560)

Boston Baked Beans

$6.99/lb
$6.64/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(832)

Original Mike & Ike®

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(437)

Ginger Balls

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(589)

Creme Drops

$8.99/lb
$8.54/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(983)

Chick-O-Stick Bites

$7.99/lb
$7.59/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(649)

Lemon Drops

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(579)

Gummy Red and Black Raspberries

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(554)

Circus Peanuts

$7.99/lb
$7.59/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(662)

Good & Plenty

$6.99/lb
$6.64/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(752)

Caramels

$6.99/lb
$6.64/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(451)

Tootsie Roll Minis (Flavored)

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(380)

Hot Tamales

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(400)

Peppermint Patty

$6.99/lb
$6.64/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(613)

Red Australian Licorice

$7.99/lb
$7.59/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(506)

Coconut Stacks

$8.99/lb
$8.54/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(676)

Buttermints

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(489)

Clove Balls

$3.99/lb
$3.79/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(449)

White Chocolate Almond Bark

$9.99
$9.49
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
8oz bag
(501)

Cherry Drops

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(418)

Lemonheads

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(289)

Salt Water Taffy (Sugar-Free)

$9.99/lb
$9.49/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(424)

Chiclets Gum

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(232)

Red Licorice Wheels

$6.99/lb
$6.64/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(299)

Starlight Mints

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(204)

Tootsie Roll Minis

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(397)

Skittles ®

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(194)

Black Licorice Wheels

$6.99/lb
$6.64/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(334)

Reese's Pieces

$8.99/lb
$8.54/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(182)

Jelly Belly® Buttered Popcorn

$10.99/lb
$10.44/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(281)

Assorted Fruit Sours

$5.99/lb
$5.69/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(194)

Smarties

$4.99/lb
$4.74/lb
Save 5% with Auto-Delivery
(237)