Skip to main content
FREE shipping on orders over $59!
Main Content

Oh My! Pecan Pie

Out of stock!

Sorry, this item is out of stock until Mon, Nov 1 (a month from now).

Enter your email to be notified when product becomes available.

Order now and we'll ship tomorrow.

Sink your teeth into the most amazing pecan pie under the sky! We don’t use measly, thumbnail-sized nuts in this pie, we use only our premium, premium-sized pecans so you’re guaranteed to have a mouthful of pecans in every single bite. If you love the ooey-gooey center of pecan pie, this one is going to deliver. Baked by hand in small batches, we promise this pie tastes deliciously homemade.

Save $10 with our new 5 pack of pies! Perfect for stocking up for all your holiday gatherings and gift-giving!

This price includes special insulated packaging.

Note: We encourage you to ship the pie one or two days prior to the date you intend it to be enjoyed.

To Enjoy Our Oh My! Pecan Pie

1) Remove the pie from the silver insulated pouch that it is shipped in.

2) If you plan on eating this right away (we certainly recommend tasting this treat early and often) allow the pie to sit at room temperature for three hours and then dig right in!

3) If you like your pie warm (and who doesn’t?!) you can reheat it in the oven at 300°F for 15-20 minutes. Add a scoop of vanilla ice cream and whipped cream to complete this most delectable treat.

Storage Tips

1) Your pie will last for up to five days in the refrigerator.

2) Want to freeze your pie to enjoy later? It pe-can be done! We recommend freezing it as soon as you receive it. It will keep for up to 180 days in an air-tight freezer bag.

Ratings & Reviews

1937 Ratings
5 star
4 star
3 star
2 star
1 star
December 15, 2020
OMG! This is an insanely good pie. Amazingly, it is not too sweet! It has a delicate flavor and is completely addictive.
, Yelm, WA
December 7, 2020
Too sweet & gummy.
, Canton, MS
December 6, 2020
It's still in freezer but if it is like the last one, it's fabulous
, San Rafael, CA
December 5, 2020
Best pecan pie ever! Fresh and luscious! AAA+ recommended! Why don’t you have them for Christmas too? Would love to give as gifts! Thanks a bunch!
, Pineville, KY
Showing 1-4 of 989


Corn Syrup, Pecans, Wheat Flour, Sugar, Eggs, Palm and Soybean Oil Shortening, Water, Butter, Margarine, Sugared Egg Yolks, Dextrose, Salt, Vanilla Extract. Packaged in the same facility as peanuts, tree nuts, wheat, soy, and milk products.

Nutrition Facts

Serving size 137g (~4.8 oz.)

Amount per serving
Calories from Fat351
Total Fat39g50%
Saturated Fat8g40%
Total Carbohydrate67g24%
Dietary Fiber3g11%
Vitamin A0%
Vitamin C0%

More Info

Country of origin: United States

ID: 4903